Amato's - South Portland Menu (Updated 2026)

Amato’s - South Portland stands out as a true Maine culinary gem, specializing in authentic Italian sandwiches and more. Located on Broadway, this no-frills, takeaway spot is beloved for its fresh, soft bread and perfectly balanced sandwich oil blend that elevates every bite. Their menu offers a rich variety, from the classic Real Italian cold cut loaded with genoa salami and prosciutto to standout options like the Large Tuna Salad Italian and All Natural Turkey Italian. Noteworthy extras like Italian sausage, garlic bread sticks, and meat or veggie Stuffers served with marinara sauce add delightful layers to the experience. Customers praise Amato’s for consistently fresh ingredients, generous portions, and warm, attentive service—qualities that make visiting here feel like coming home. Whether it’s the flavorful ham Italian or the famous Sausage Parmesan, Amato’s delivers a satisfying and memorable taste of Maine’s Italian sandwich tradition every time.

The menu features a variety of Italian-inspired dishes, with a strong emphasis on sandwiches, specialty pasta dinners, and 14" large pizzas. Small cold sandwiches range from $6.59 to $9.49, offering budget-friendly options suitable for lighter meals or quick takeout. Specialty pasta dinners and large pizzas are priced between approximately $11 and $21, indicating a mid-range to premium segment for more substantial dining occasions. The presence of both smaller sandwich portions and full pasta dinners suggests flexibility for different meal times, with sandwiches fitting well for lunch and pizza or pasta for dinner. The pricing structure supports a spectrum from casual to more filling Italian meals within the $10–20 range typical for the location.